🔗 Share this article

One of some of the most iconic pictures from modern history shows a nude young girl, her hands extended, her expression distorted in pain, her body scorched and flaking. She appears dashing in the direction of the lens as fleeing a bombing within South Vietnam. To her side, other children also run away from the destroyed community of the region, against a scene of dark smoke along with troops.

The International Impact of a Single Photograph

Within hours the distribution during the Vietnam War, this image—officially called "The Terror of War"—evolved into a traditional sensation. Viewed and analyzed globally, it's generally hailed for galvanizing public opinion critical of the US war in Southeast Asia. One noted author later commented that this deeply lasting image featuring the child the girl in agony likely was more effective to heighten popular disgust against the war than a hundred hours of shown atrocities. A legendary British photojournalist who reported on the war described it the most powerful image from the so-called “The Television War”. Another experienced war journalist declared that the photograph is quite simply, among the most significant photos in history, particularly of the Vietnam war.

The Long-Held Attribution Followed by a New Claim

For half a century, the image was attributed to the work of Nick Út, a young local photographer working for a major news agency in Saigon. However a provocative latest investigation released by a popular platform claims that the iconic picture—often hailed as the pinnacle of combat photography—might have been shot by someone else at the location in Trảng Bàng.

As presented in the documentary, The Terror of War may have been taken by a freelancer, who offered the images to the AP. The assertion, along with the documentary's subsequent research, originates with a former editor an ex-staffer, who alleges how a dominant bureau head directed him to reassign the image’s credit from the stringer to Út, the sole AP staff photographer there at the time.

This Search to find Answers

The former editor, now in his 80s, emailed an investigator recently, asking for assistance to locate the uncredited stringer. He expressed that, if he was still living, he hoped to offer an acknowledgment. The investigator considered the freelance photographers he had met—comparing them to the stringers of today, just as local photographers during the war, are often overlooked. Their work is commonly doubted, and they function amid more challenging conditions. They lack insurance, no retirement plans, minimal assistance, they frequently lack good equipment, and they are extremely at risk while photographing within their homeland.

The filmmaker wondered: How would it feel for the individual who took this photograph, if in fact it wasn't Nick Út?” As an image-maker, he imagined, it would be deeply distressing. As a student of war photography, especially the vaunted war photography of the era, it would be reputation-threatening, possibly legacy-altering. The hallowed history of "Napalm Girl" among the diaspora meant that the director who had family emigrated at the time was hesitant to pursue the film. He expressed, I hesitated to challenge the accepted account that credited Nick the image. Nor did I wish to disrupt the existing situation of a community that had long admired this accomplishment.”

The Inquiry Develops

Yet both the journalist and the director felt: it was necessary asking the question. When reporters are to hold others accountable,” noted the journalist, we must be able to address tough issues about our own field.”

The investigation documents the team as they pursue their own investigation, from discussions with witnesses, to call-outs in modern Saigon, to examining footage from other footage captured during the incident. Their search lead to an identity: Nguyễn Thành Nghệ, working for a television outlet during the attack who occasionally sold photographs to foreign agencies on a freelance basis. According to the documentary, a moved Nghệ, now also advanced in age residing in the United States, attests that he sold the image to the news organization for minimal payment and a copy, but was haunted by not being acknowledged for decades.

The Backlash and Further Investigation

The man comes across in the film, thoughtful and calm, however, his claim turned out to be explosive within the world of war photography. {Days before|Shortly prior to